In the Judgement, the Plaintiff, Catherine Rucker, was declared to be the "prevailing party." Basically, the reason why the PMA Board finally concluded an election to fill all 5 director positions on April 10, 2026, was because Catherine Rucker had filed her lawsuit in December 2023 As a result, Catherine Rucker was the "catalyst" who forced the PMA Board to do its job.
06232026_Judgment (pdf)
DownloadOn September 6, 2023, the PMA filed a claim on its Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance policy with the Continental Casualty Insurance Company. See the March 29, 2024, letter about the claim. Although the letter does not state which company was involved with the claim, it was Continental Casualty. For example, see the 2024 PMA insurance summary, which shows $1,000,000 in coverage for the Continental Casualty policy, effective 120122 to 120123.
In July 2023, 19 PMA Members submitted a Petition for the PMA Board to carry out an election to fill all five (5) Director positions, with staggered terms. The PMA Board waited until March 2024 to comply with the Petition - which was several months after the Plaintiff filed her lawsuit in December 2023. In August 2024, the PMA Board finally issued a "call for candidates" notice for the 2025 election to fill all 5 director positions, with staggered terms, and the election concluded on April 10, 2025.
This website is provided by a Pointe Marin Association Member who assists the members by sharing copies of the Association's governing documents, annual reports, notices, and development maps. The information herein has been carefully checked, is believed to be accurate, but is presented here for information purposes only and without any claims as to reliability and without assuming liability for any errors. The PMA Board's website is https://pointmarinhoa.com. If you want to use the Board's website, registration is required for access and your personal information will be shared with unpaid volunteers.